• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

  • Privacy Policy

Multiculturiosity

Exploring food traditions through (mostly) healthy, gluten-free recipes, restaurants and travel

  • Recipes
    • Asian
    • African
    • American
    • Breads
    • Chinese
    • Canning and Preserves
    • Chicken & Poultry
    • Cooking With Booze
    • Desserts
    • Fish and Seafood
    • French
    • Fruit
    • Gluten-Free & Dairy-Free
    • Greek
    • Greens & Herbs
    • Honey & Maple Syrup
    • Indian
    • Italian
    • Japanese
    • Korean
    • Local
    • Main Dishes
    • Sides
    • Vegetarian
  • Restaurants
    • Fine Dining
    • Casual Dining
    • Gluten-Free & Gluten-Free Friendly
    • Vegetarian & Vegetarian-Friendly
  • My Montreal
  • About
  • Cookbooks I Love
  • Food & Travel Writing
  • Quarantine Cooking E-Book
  • 5à7 Podcast with Amie Watson

Wild Atlantic Cod in Fennel, Cumin and Fenugreek-Spiced Tomato Sauce

April 2, 2011 MissWattson Leave a Comment

Sometimes it’s nice to treat yourself a little, and I’m pretty sure Michael gets this. So we hit it off.

To describe Michael as “well-groomed” would be an understatement: tailored, pleated pants, ironed shirt, and nails that were prettier than mine. But he almost immediately assured me he wasn’t gay…which I’m not sure if I believe.

To be fair, I’m not the type of woman who gets her nails done. I chop mine off about once a week so I can be a better rock-climber. So if Michael thought I was the type of woman who files, buffs, and polishes, he had another thing coming.

Actually, only his thumb was prettier than mine. That was the only one he treated carefully because that was the only one you see when he’s polishing yours. So we stood in the middle of the National Women’s Show at the Palais de Congres in Montreal with him explaining to me that the rectangular prism in his hand had one side of cotton and three other sides of varying coarseness and materials to make your nails soften and glow.

“This is the nicest my nails have been in years,” I said two minutes into our meeting. “Can you use it on your feet too?”

“I would use it on your feet.” I glance up to check the innocence of the statement, and return my gaze to my polished fingers, undecided.

“Would your boyfriend use it on your feet for you?” Aha!

He was a good salesman – charming – flirting his way to a sale. I never buy these types of products. They’re nice to sample, and then you walk away.

“How old are you?” he asks lightly.

“Too young for you, probably.” I smile. Two can play at this game, and sometimes it’s nice to have a little fun…

…which is why I decided to treat myself by making this special cod dish with a not-overpowering fennel, cumin, and fenugreek tomato sauce. A treat. Just for me, which is what all those women at the Palais de Congrès were thinking when they purchased their over-priced beauty products, chocolate, and enetered their names in draws for prizes. Being on a mailing list is not generally considered a prize. So making myself a good dinner with fish is a relatively guaranteed win.

This recipe is from “At Home with Madhur Jaffrey”, which has a lot of simple fish recipes involving spice pastes and simple baking or grilling. I used the last of my summer canned tomatoes and whipped it together for what tasted like a royal treat but was actually very easy to make.

cod-in-indian-tomato-sauce

Cod in Indian-Spiced Tomato Sauce

1 lb cod* (or more sustainable haddock or mackerel)

salt, pepper and cayenne

1/8 tsp ground turmeric

1 tbsp olive oil (or canola or mustard or whatever you have. I used sunflower)

1/8 tsp ground asafetida (I grate 1/8 tsp from a big chunk since it stays fresher longer this way)

1/4 tsp mustard seeds (black or yellow, but I think black is more traditional)

1/2 tsp whole cumin seeds

1/4 tsp whole fennel seeds

1/8 whole fenugreek seeds

4 medium tomatoes that actually taste like something, grated. (The Lufa farm tomatoes I have work well as long as I use the medium ones and not the beefsteak ones that are too acidic and watery. It’s not tomato season, so if you’re using grocery store imported or greenhouse tomatoes, the odds of getting lacklustre tomatoes are great. Either way, definitely use organic tomatoes with this recipe for flavour. You need to grate them to get rid of their skins, so if you absolutely have to use canned tomatoes, just push as much through the grater as you can manage.)

1 cup fresh or frozen peas (defrosted if frozen. I wish it was pea season. I also generally double the vegetable content so I end up eating more green than protein, so up to 2 cups of peas is fine here. It just isn’t as pretty, but I care about the visual about as much as I care about my nails…sometimes)

3 tbsp probiotic plain organic yogurt (preferably a thick one. My favourite is Pinehedge, but I also like Organic Meadow. A thick one is better than a thin one, and god help you if you go with a fat free one that will end up thin and bitter…much like you will)

Directions:

1. Take the frozen peas out of the freezer to defrost!

2. Wash the fish and dry with paper towels. Place in a large dish or bowl. Sprinkle a little salt (about 1/4-1/2 tsp), a few grinds of fresh pepper (or 1/8 tsp), 1/4 tsp of cayenne, and the turmeric on the fish (both sides) and let marinate in the fridge for at least 30 minutes.

3. Heat the oil in a large frying pan on medium-high heat. When it gets hot enough (test with a few drops of water – the water should sizzle) add the grated asafetida, followed by the mustard seeds, cumin, fennel and fenugreek. Let the mustard seeds start to pop (you may need to stir them a little in the oil) and then add the grated tomatoes, 1/4 tsp salt, 1/4 tsp cayenne (don’t worry. It’ll be fine), and a little more black pepper (about 1/8 tsp).

4. Stir and cook for about 5-7 minutes, until the tomatoes thicken slightly. You want a sauce to remain though, so if the tomatoes start sticking to the bottom of the pan you need to add about 1/4 cup of water to thin it.

5. Then add the peas. If they’re not defrosted they mess with the temperature of the contents of the frying pan and mess up your carefully measured fish-cooking time. Madhur Jaffrey says to stir and cook another minute, but she lives in England – home of mushy peas – so I say just skip immediately to the next step.

6. Add the fish carefully to the pan. Often the fish will have a thin tail that will cook faster than the thicker parts of the fillet. So tuck the tail underneath (as though it’s ashamed for having been caught) and then spoon the sauce over top of the fish, basting it in the spiced tomato juices.

7. Cover the pan, leaving it just a little ajar, and let the fish cook for about 7-10 minutes, until it’s just cooked through. It should not longer be transluscent, and it should fall apart when you touch it with a knife. When you bite into it it shouldn’t be chewy or tough. If it tastes “like chicken” it’s over-cooked. It should be soft and delicate (like fish!!!). I’d recommend basting the fish a few times in this 7-10 minute period and also making sure there’s always enough liquid in the pan so the sauce doesn’t burn. Add a little extra water if need be – about a tbsp at a time as needed.

So the peas are ugly, I know. You can make this dish without the peas and you just lose a little sweetness and green nutrition, but the recipe can’t see you and neither can I. I’d especially recommend skipping the peas if you’re serving this for company or kids. It just looks better without them. Serve another green vegetable on the side, or better yet, a salad in a separate bowl or plate. Bright red and dark green look weird on a single plate together, in my opinion.

But Indian food isn’t supposed to look gorgeous. It’s supposed to be delicious, and this is.

*Normally I would never, ever, ever cook with Atlantic cod since the stocks are so low and for goodness sake I’m from Newfoundland where cod moratorium of 1992 destroyed a lot of my province’s livelihood, so overfishing now is the last thing I want to encourage. But I got this fish from a single fisherman in Nova Scotia who had a government-given quota. That doesn’t mean the stocks are necessarily very high, but he was allowed to fish it and he did, and he was earning a living. The sad thing is he can’t even reach his quota because there just aren’t enough cod to catch…It’s not him going out in a huge dredger and hauling up every life-form on the sea bottom. So the morals of having this fish are somewhat gray, but leaning toward white.

All Recipes, Fish and Seafood, Indian, Main Dishes fish in fenugreek-fennel tomato sauce, Indian fish recipe, Indian seafood recipe, madhur jaffrey fish recipe, sustainable seafood cod

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Sign up for my newsletter and all the food (writing) will come to you!








Flashbacks:

Tomato Relish: This has Nothing To Do With A Hotdog Condiment…

July 11, 2010 By MissWattson Leave a Comment

This is … [Read More...] about Tomato Relish: This has Nothing To Do With A Hotdog Condiment…

Not So “Flat and Chewy” Chocolate Chip Cookies, and a Better, Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip-less Version

December 19, 2012 By Leave a Comment

So there … [Read More...] about Not So “Flat and Chewy” Chocolate Chip Cookies, and a Better, Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip-less Version

And We Called Him Lumphini…

February 10, 2014 By

My … [Read More...] about And We Called Him Lumphini…

“It’s a Jambalaya-laya”: Spicy Lamb Sausage and Chicken

August 17, 2010 By MissWattson Leave a Comment

When I … [Read More...] about “It’s a Jambalaya-laya”: Spicy Lamb Sausage and Chicken

Videos

June 2025
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  
« Mar    

Archives

Tags

alice medrich amie watson aux vivres becky selengut best montreal restaurants best restaurants montreal bonnie stern chicken & poultry cooking classes montreal crudessence dairy-free gluten-free gluten-free montreal gluten-free restaurants montreal gluten free good fish hari nayak healthy vegetarian recipes heartsmart cooking how to make sushi jean-talon market lima lufa farms made with love modernist cuisine montreal montreal en lumiere montreal farmers markets montreal gazette montreal highlights festival montreal restaurants montreal restaurant week my indian kitchen natural wine oenopole peru plenty raspipav rezin sustainable seafood montreal toque! toronto vegan vegan restaurants montreal yotam ottolenghi

Copyright © 2025 · Daily Dish Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in